So, I used a lvl 161 Artifact Ring design with a lvl 166 5* Essence on a fresh cele ring. Item goes red, I'm excited, use a 1m scroll for it to turn White. Combined total of 350gg's wasted, my perogative to buy des/ess of course, I understand that. What I don't get is, why is it an item which is successfully upgraded with the combination of mats, does it then fail on identification? Surely it should give me some sort of a star outturn? Can anyone explain it? People may say I've "overcooked" it with the mats, I've used much higher combinations and had great outturns.